WASHINGTON -- There are packing boxes now in her spacious Treasury Department office overlooking the White House, and there will soon be a new
treasury secretary overseeing gun issues and, with a new administration, probably a new gun-control policy.
But as she gets ready to leave her obscure job as senior adviser for firearms
policy coordination to the under secretary of the treasury for enforcement,
Susan Ginsburg can take satisfaction that she has presided over what some law- enforcement officials and academic specialists call one of the most
important accomplishments of the Clinton administration. With no public recognition, she has helped transform the understanding of how criminals and
juveniles get guns, an achievement that has provided new ways to crack down
on the illegal firearms market.
Susan Ginsburg - USDT
| Before Ms. Ginsburg, it was widely believed
that little could be done to prevent criminals
from getting guns. There were roughly 200
million firearms in America, and the thinking
was that criminals simply stole their weapons
from that huge supply.
But Ms. Ginsburg helped arrange for the
Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms to
undertake widespread tracing of guns used
in crime, and as a result it is now known that
most criminals buy their firearms from
licensed dealers, gun traffickers or straw purchasers. That in turn has led
police agencies across the nation to make targets of corrupt dealers and illicit
traffickers for the first time.
"To put what she did in perspective, it's like saying that up till five years ago,
nobody had been doing any drug enforcement," said David Kennedy, a senior researcher at the John F Kennedy School of Government, at Harvard.
Philip J. Cook, a professor of public policy at Duke, turns to the Bible for a
comparison. "Susan reminds me of the story of the miracle of the loaves and
fishes," he said. "She may not have had a staff," he said, and she worked under the shadow of the National Rifle Association and its allies in Congress,
but she essentially created a new federal policy out of little more than
some abstruse academic thinking. "She has really been one of my heroes."
At least as remarkable, in contemporary Washington, Ms. Ginsburg has never
been quoted by name in a newspaper or appeared on television. Her anonymity is such that when asked his reaction to her work, even Bill Powers,
the chief spokesman for the N.R.A., said he had never heard of her.
That is precisely how Ms. Ginsburg, wary of gun-control politics and modest
as well, has wanted it. "I've been very disciplined about not seeking publicity,"
she said. Even when she knew this profile of her was being written, she insisted in a cascade of messages that the real credit should go to Treasury
Secretary Lawrence H. Summers, people at the firearms bureau and the academic researchers who first suggested to her the possibilities of gun
MS. GINSBURG, 47 and divorced, says she does not know where she will be working next. She likes to garden, read and run marathons. But her idea of a
good weekend has been to spend hours preparing a report on tracing crime guns.
She was born in Washington and is a graduate of Bryn Mawr and the University of Pennsylvania Law School. She feels a need, she says, to serve
"the public good," an inclination she admits can lead to being labeled "naïve
or disingenuous today."
She inherited this, she said, from her father, David Ginsburg, who as a young
lawyer from Huntington, W.Va., went to work for the New Deal administration
of President Franklin D. Roosevelt and became a clerk for a Supreme Court justice, William O. Douglas. Mr. Ginsburg was a co-founder of Americans for
Democratic Action and the author of the Kerner Commission report on civil disorders, which warned that the United States was in danger of becoming
two nations — one black, one white.
Ms. Ginsburg had no special interest in gun control when in 1995, as an official at the Treasury Department, the firearms bureau's parent, she was
invited to an academic conference in Santa Fe, N.M., on youth violence.
It was there that scholars like Mr. Kennedy and Professor Cook explained to
her their new findings suggesting that criminals were buying their guns, directly or indirectly, from licensed dealers, rather than stealing them.
"I became an accidental convert," Ms. Ginsburg said. "It was my job to translate their ideas into policy," some of which she did in telephone calls with
them lasting up to 10 hours, without an interruption for a meal.
Ms. Ginsburg then put the resources of the firearms bureau to work, greatly
increasing the number of crime guns it traced. By now, the agency has recruited 50 cities and 6 states to trace all guns they recover in crimes.
The research has produced some crucial findings. For example, it has shown
that only a small fraction of dealers, 1.2 percent of the total, accounted for
more than half of crime guns traced in 1998. At the same time, it has underscored the scholars' initial discovery that
criminals and juveniles want only certain guns: high-powered semiautomatic
handguns of a kind widely available only in the last few years.
Contrary to the experience of earlier years, when the N.R.A.'s supporters in
Congress kept the firearms agency's budget small, Ms. Ginsburg came up with a way to diffuse Congressional opposition. By focusing on criminal
conduct by scofflaw dealers and criminals' acquisition of guns, she found a
middle ground between gun-control advocates and the rifle association that
has broad political appeal.
The result, she said, is that in the budget passed by Congress last week, there is money to hire 500 new
ATF agents. That will be the first real expansion in agent staffing since the bureau was created nearly three